Bent Out of Shape: Has Heavy Metal Become a Joke? Part 2 — the Power of the Blues
Gary Moore
Related Content
A couple of weeks ago, I wrote a blog post about heavy metal that provoked a strong reaction, both positive and negative.
I want to follow up on the subject to try and further share my point of view and address some of the comments it received.
The most important thing to remember is that I'm just voicing an opinion, and I'm not an authority on the subject, just a fan.
Some of the comments I received were directed at me personally and questioned my musicianship. All of these comments were related to bands and releases I wasn't even involved with at the point of reference.
For the record, my playing and songwriting is only on one official release. That's my self-titled debut album released in 2012 via Metal Mind Productions.
For judging purposes, take a listen and feel free to say whatever you want. I don't mind being judged, but only as long as it's for something I've actually played on!
Now let's focus on the subject of the blues and how metal seems to have lost its blues roots. I saw some comments that said some people were glad the blues was no longer a part of metal and that lead guitarists had evolved beyond the blues scale. All I can say in response to those comments is you're missing the point!
The blues goes beyond just a scale. It's more than just the six notes. The blues has nothing to do with what a musician plays. It's all about the feel, emotion, passion and conviction behind what a musician plays. The blues is something you feel from within and can be expressed in many different ways, including through heavy metal.
It's my opinion that the best music provokes an emotional response from the listener, and the reason I feel so dissatisfied after listening to the majority of modern metal bands is I don't feel any emotion toward the music. I can't feel what the musicians are trying to express, and I'm almost certain it is because they lack the blues.
But how do you define the blues? For me it's a sense of loneliness and struggle that is expressed through music, regardless of genre. One man and his guitar against the world. It is developed through real-life experience. It's about attitude and rebellion. Its also about love. It might not be considered very metal, but a broken heart will create one of the strongest emotions any human will feel in their lifetime. A real musician wouldn't be afraid to express these emotions through their playing. I'm not saying you have to sing love songs, but musicians should draw upon their life experiences to give meaning to their music.
As an example, listen to Gary Moore. Here's a solo that's pure emotion. You can feel the power of the blues within him, even though he barely plays the blues scale. In my opinion, this is heavier than the majority of metal today. It hits you in a way only a master musician can. What's even more unbelievable is that this solo was totally improvised!
To finish, I want to point out that there are also some fast players or shredders who do play with emotion and the blues. I don't think all shredders are robots. Eddie Van Halen would be at the top of my list as a player who has combined most perfectly speed and feel.
I know there's going to be a strong reaction to what I write. I find it difficult to put into words exactly what I'm trying to communicate, but hopefully you will get the general idea.
Don't hate me just because I have an opinion. I wish bigger musicians would talk about the things they don't like about current music and not be afraid to share their opinion. Nothing annoys me more than big musicians who, when asked about newer bands in interviews, never have anything negative to say, as if they like everything.
I started playing guitar because I wanted to make a musical statement and was unhappy with what I heard from new bands and their guitarists. Whether or not I achieve my goal, I can always rest easy knowing I've never gone against my personal values as a musician. Cheers.
Will Wallner is a guitarist from England currently living in Los Angeles. He recently signed a solo deal with Polish record label 'Metal Mind Productions' for the release of his debut album which features influential musicians from Hard Rock/Heavy Metal. He is also the lead guitarist for 'White Wizzard' (Earache Records) and in 2012 toured Japan, America and Canada. Follow Will on http://www.facebook.com/wallnervain and https://twitter.com/willwallner.
Will Wallner is a guitarist from England now living in Los Angeles. He recently signed a solo deal with Polish record label Metal Mind Productions for the release of his debut album, which features influential musicians from hard rock and heavy metal. He also is the lead guitarist for White Wizzard (Earache Records) and in 2012 toured Japan, America and Canada. Follow Will on Facebook and Twitter.
Related
![]()
j4bis
December 27, 2012 at 11:09pm
Hi Will! I am a 45 year old die hard metal fan and I totally understand the points you're making. I've been saying similar statements for years. The emotions and feelings that are somehow captured within certain recordings; and then somehow pass through the music, to the listener, is what I believe most current metal has been lacking for a long time.
There are emotions that overwhelm me and I can actually feel them in the music when I listen to Pantera's: Vulgar Display of Power, several Iron Maiden recordings, Guns N' Roses: Appetite for Destruction, just to name a few. Another personal observation I've made is that most of the "feelings" I refer to begin negatively. It's like the anger of Metallica's James Hetfield is actually reaching me personally from their early recordings. Listening to Rage Against the Machine can also provide this effect for me. Blues musicians will tell you the same thing. The "Blues" are just negative feelings and emotions being passed through music. I don't mean to imply that all music is negative but I personally feel most METAL music that I love has a certain anger OR angst vibe.
I have a 17 year old son who plays in two progressive metal bands. Their influences are more of the modern metal genre such as Veil of Maya, Periphery, After the Burial, Beneath the Masses, Animals as Leaders, etc... They are good but I've been trying to help them understand that almost all GREAT music has more EMOTION or at least as much as, technical skill. The above-referenced Gary Moore video is a FANTASTIC example. They just think I'm an old man who doesn't know anything about "current" music.
I do NOT want metal to be back in the mainstream again but I believe it's a lost genre of music right now. It's MY opinion that metal music is lacking the feeling it once had because there is nothing to rebel against anymore. My parents were AFRAID of hard rock and heavy metal but now that MY generation, which grew up on hard rock and metal from the 70's and 80's are the "grown ups", we know music shouldn't be feared... or should it?
Another observation I've made is that MOST bands begin to lose their "musical passion" when they become successful. The more successful they become, the LESS feeling is in their music. The success removes their passion. I KNOW the music is great when I listen to it, THEN, I want to SHARE it with others because the music excited me.
I don't know what the answer is but I still want music to MOVE me! Thanks for listening, or I should say... reading.
Joel
![]()
matklok
December 29, 2012 at 6:55pm
The laser sounds in the last solo where cool. As for Gary Moore being heavier than most metal today, i don't think so, but his solos are better than most metal players today. A lot of the American metal bands today have solos that are more like just a bunch of noise, fast playing and no melody. I would look to the European bands for melodic players. Bands like Children of Bodom, Sonata Arctica, Stratovarius, Hevisaurus, SauruXet, and Nightwish. All of which use the blues and emotion in their playing. But there are also a good amount of American bands out there too. But I agree that of the hundreds of well known metal bands out there, only a few play with the feel that you talk of.
![]()
fegtri17
December 27, 2012 at 2:11pm
I think that most types of music can provoke emotions, but one person will ~feel~ only a fraction of these types of music.
I feel the blues, the classic rock, the heavy metal, the death metal, even some rap.
Classical music does not reach me. Complicated abstract jazz does not reach me. Dubstep does not reach me (but I don't care that they exist and let them exist).
... and death metal does not seem to reach you.
It does not mean that metal is on the WRONG path.I wish you the best of luck if you plan to bring metal back on the track you want it to be.













