5 times a live version of a song was better than the studio recording

Stevie Ray Vaughan performs in Saratoga, New York, September 1, 1986 (Image credit: Paul Natkin/Getty Images)

For musicians, spending time to craft a song, capture the right performance and produce a recording with just the right combination of effects and overdubs is an art unto itself. 

However, there are instances throughout rock history when an artist’s whole-hearted attempt to convey a feeling in the studio has paled in comparison to a good old-fashioned, off-the-cuff live performance. Here are just a few examples when a live version of a song outshines the original studio take.  

1. Led Zeppelin - Black Dog (How the West Was Won)

It's hard to imagine that Led Zeppelin IV’s opening track, Black Dog, could rock any harder than it already does. But this version on How the West Was Won - a live album released in 2003 featuring two 1972 performances in Southern California - gives it a run for its money.

It's no secret that the recordings were extensively edited before being released to the public, but regardless, it showcases Zeppelin at what many consider to be their peak, and the band sounds exceptionally ferocious - especially Page's guitar. 

2. Stevie Ray Vaughan - Texas Flood (Live Alive)

When it comes to Stevie Ray Vaughan's guitar god status, Texas Flood sets the bar pretty high. Yet, the studio version on his 1983 debut falls slightly flat compared to this performance on 1987’s Live Alive, recorded at the Montreux Jazz Festival.

Part of Stevie's greatness was his ability to play in the moment - to let his fingers speak his emotion - and that's what you hear on this version of the song.

3. The Allman Brothers Band - Whipping Post (At Fillmore East)

When you compare the studio take against the At Fillmore East version of the Allman Brothers Band's Whipping Post, they have little in common. The original recording, included on the band's 1969 debut, clocks in at a little over five minutes. Meanwhile, the Fillmore version takes up the entire side of an LP, at over 22 minutes long. 

More than that though, it captures the band at their best, pushing the envelope of song structure and improvisation, with guitarists Duane Allman and Dickey Betts trading phenomenal solos. 

4. Nirvana - All Apologies (MTV Unplugged in New York) 

Nirvana's MTV Unplugged album, released in 1994, showcased a side of the Kurt Cobain that was rarely on display.

Playing their instruments loudly was an essential part of the band's dynamic, but stripping this away put Kurt's incredible sense of melody - and his voice - in plain view. It's in this setting that songs like All Apologies, which originally appears on 1993's In Utero, shine especially brightly.

5. Jimi Hendrix - Voodoo Child (Slight Return) (Live at Woodstock) 

With its far-out guitar solos that pan sporadically from the left to right speaker, the studio recording of Voodoo Child (Slight Return) - the closing track on 1968's Electric Ladyland - is memorable by itself. But Hendrix frequently took the song to otherworldly places live, and the performance at Woodstock on August 19, 1969, is a prime example. 

With a faster tempo - and the addition of rhythm guitarist Larry Lee and conga players Juma Sultan and Jerry Velez - the band careened their way through a thirteen-minute Voodoo Child, punctuated by Hendrix's incredibly cathartic solos that rival the original recordings.

Thank you for reading 5 articles this month**

Join now for unlimited access

US pricing $3.99 per month or $39.00 per year

UK pricing £2.99 per month or £29.00 per year 

Europe pricing €3.49 per month or €34.00 per year

*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription

Join now for unlimited access

Prices from £2.99/$3.99/€3.49