This is a little unorthodox, as I know you’re raring to get into some serious discussion about the best guitar strap locks, but I’d like to tell you a story first. When I was 14, I bought myself my first nice guitar – an ebony and gold Aria PE. I’d been saving money from birthdays and odd jobs for what felt like an eternity to get something that felt and sounded great.
Best guitar strap locks: Product guide
Material: Hardened steel
Finishes: Chrome, Satin Chrome, Black Chrome, Nickel, Ruthenium, Gold, Copper, Satin Pearl
Style: Strap-fitted
+ High-quality build
+ Suitable for thicker straps
+ Range of finishes
- They’re a bit predictable
Schaller is perhaps the most famous and well-used strap lock manufacturer out there. Alongside Jim Dunlop, the German company is one of the earliest innovators in this field, having first developed its product in 1981. Fast forward to 2018, and it took on user feedback to launch an improved S-Locks design and hold on to its industry-standard status.
Working on a pull-pin-style system, S-Locks are easy to take off when need be, but sit firmly enough that you don’t have to worry about any accidents. Their extra-long threads make them more suitable for thicker straps than any other product on this list. And these guys are also pretty easy to install, with the button and screw coming as a set piece that you can just screw into place with an allen key.
Material: Steel
Finishes: Chrome, Nickel, Black Chrome, Gold, Antique Copper, Antique Brass, Skull Gunmetal/Black, Victorian, Black Victorian, Henry and Mary
Style: Strap-fitted
+ Low-profile button
+ Easy to install
+ Unique and effective fastening system
- Can only be fixed with the provided tool, so don’t lose it!
Schaller and Jim Dunlop could justifiably describe themselves as the ‘big two’ of the strap lock world at the moment – however, if this set is anything to go by, German firm Loxx could soon be joining them.
Based on mechanisms designed for the auto industry, the Loxx Strap Lock Set for Electric Guitar & Bass comprises low-profile pull-pin systems that are neatly cased in smart little buttons. They’re easy off and on, but unlikely to pop off.
One of the best things about the set is the provided fixing tool, which is basically a cross between a spanner and a two-prong case wrench. Look after it, though, as it’s proprietary, meaning you’ll need it to make any adjustments.
Material: Hardened steel
Finishes: Nickel, Black, Black Nickel, Brass, Gold
Style: Strap-fitted
+ Well-priced
+ Great functionality
+ Range of different finishes
- Might not fit so well with snug hard cases
Like the Schaller S-Locks, the Jim Dunlop StrapLok Strap Retainers Dual Design (SLS1031N) have carved out a longstanding reputation for quality and reliability.
However, whereas Schaller’s locks work on a pull-pin-style system, these have a button-style release, which means they’re a little harder to get on and off but less prone to accidental releases. One thing to note about button-style locks is that they sit a fair way off the guitar, meaning it won’t fit so well inside a snug hard case with the strap on.
Overall, though, Jim Dunlop’s strap locks are a superb offering and a great alternative to the Schaller S-Locks, especially given their more affordable price point.
Material: Hardened steel
Finishes: Black, Gold, Nickel
Style: Strap-fitted
+ Easy to install
+ No rattling
- On the pricier side
While D’Addario can hardly be thought of as a newcomer to this scene, its PW-SLS-02 Universal Strap Locks are one of the more recent additions to the market. Launched in 2018, they’ve taken off in a pretty big way, becoming a fierce competitor to Schaller and Jim Dunlop’s offerings.
For good reason, too. Working on a pull-pin-style system, D’Addario’s locks are functional and boast a short profile that sits very neatly alongside your guitar body – something D’Addario was conscious of when designing them.
One key feature of D’Addario’s locks is that their pull pin is mounted on a big button. This can be both a good and a bad thing. On the positive side, the larger surface area is easy to grip – handy for when you need to mount and dismount the locks. On the negative side, there’s more chance that the locks could get snagged on something. This is worst-case scenario stuff, though, and the PW-SLS-02 Universal Strap Locks are generally an efficient and effective solution.
Material: Steel
Finishes: Chrome, Black, Gold, Red
Style: Strap-fitted
+ Very functional
+ Difficult to accidentally release
+ Great for Fender owners
- Bulkier than we generally like
One of the main differences between strap lock systems is the way in which you lock them, and, while everybody will have a preference for a certain style, it’s hard to look past the Fender Infinity Strap Locks for sheer functionality.
Thanks to their smooth, ball-bearing-style system with pinch-button release, they’re incredibly easy to take off, but almost impossible to do so accidentally.
One thing to consider is that, even though they look very compact, these strap locks actually stick out a fair way, so you might need to take your strap off if you’re packing the guitar away. They do look cool, though, and would really enhance the look of your Fender.
Material: Plastic
Finishes: Black
Style: Clip
+ Very easy to install
+ Very affordable
+ Can secure your cable
- Plastic is not as sturdy as steel
While most of the strap locks in this guide are pretty simple to install, none can match the D’Addario Dual-Lock Strap Locks for ease of use. With their slide-on/slide-off, clip-style mechanism, they’re the perfect choice for people who don’t want to faff about changing buttons and threading bolts through their straps.
Of course, these being plastic clips that slide over the top of your strap, you shouldn’t expect them to be as sturdy or reliable as, say, Shaller or Ernie Ball locks – but, unless you’re turning in The Dillinger Escape Plan-style performances, they should do the job alright.
While peace of mind is worth paying for when we’re talking about valued possessions, these strap locks are significantly more affordable than just about everything else out there – and can even secure your guitar cable at the same time – so are well worth a look if you don’t want to spend a lot.
Material: Steel
Finishes: Chrome, Black, Gold
Style: Strap-fitted
+ Difficult to accidentally open
+ Very functional
+ Comparatively expensive
- Bulkier than you might want
Very comparable to the Fender Infinity Strap Locks, Ernie Ball’s Super Locks are a great option for those guitarists who like a pinch-button release.
As you’d expect from some of the most expensive strap locks on the market, the build quality here is exceptional. If only we could say the same thing about their looks.
Ultimately, that’s a matter of personal taste, though, and going on quality alone, the Ernie Ball Super Locks are a seriously safe choice that you can put your trust in.
Material: Steel
Finishes: Chrome, Black, Gold
Style: Strap-fitted
+ Most affordable steel locks
+ Well-built
+ Don't have to tighten the nut too often
- Not suitable for thicker straps
If you like the look of the Schaller S-Locks but want a more affordable alternative, then you’re in luck. Stagg’s SSL1 strap locks are basically like a budget S-Lock and, at around $14/£10 a pair, are probably the most attractively priced steel locks on the market.
While they’re a solid offering and will do pretty much everything you need them to do, the lower price point does come with a couple of trade-offs. Firstly, these strap locks have a much shorter thread, so aren’t suitable for thick straps. They also use a nut-and-washer system to secure them to the strap, so you’ll have to keep an eye on them and tighten them from time to time.
But given that you could buy almost three sets for the price of one set of other-brand steel locks, the Stagg SSL1s worth considering.
Material: Rubber
Finishes: Black, Red
Style: Block
+ Affordable
+ Very easy to install
+ Limited colour range
- Not as secure as their steel counterparts
If you’re planning on taking your guitar strap on and off a lot, and you aren’t an acrobatic performer, then you might want to consider Fender’s Strap Blocks. With their rubber build, they’re unassuming to look at, but they’re actually pretty effective.
Of course, you shouldn’t expect the same level of quality that you’ll get with other locks further up this list, but these guys are a great no-fuss, tried-and-tested option. They slide over the top of your strap and button and can be attached to your guitar in a matter of minutes. As they’re made of stiff rubber, it does take a little bit of effort to get them on, but that’s kind of reassuring.
Best guitar strap locks: Buying advice
How to choose the best strap locks for you
You can trust Guitar World Our expert reviewers spend hours testing and comparing guitar products so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about how we test.
