Kirk Hammett: my ideas get shot down by Metallica’s “tone police”

Kirk Hammett of Metallica performs live
(Image credit: Gina Wetzler/Getty Images)

Best of 2019: Although he’s best known for his wah-happy electric guitar solos in Metallica, Kirk Hammett enjoys playing much more than just metal - who could forget the times he covered Kool & the Gang, Prince and A-Ha?

Yet the thrash legend has revealed his bandmates aren’t always so open to his outside influences, during a conversation with huge Metallica fan and 21st-century guitar hero St Vincent (aka Annie Clark), as part of Rolling Stone’s Musicians on Musicians series.

I’ll play some jazz, bossa nova, blues, gypsy jazz, fucking Eastern European ballads. But no one knows I can play this stuff

“I always feel like I have so much more to say on [each] album, but I can’t say it,” Hammett begins.

“It’s crazy, because I’m so curious about music in general. I can play a lot of different stuff. I’ll play some jazz, bossa nova, blues, gypsy jazz, fucking Eastern European ballads. I play all that stuff. But no one knows I can play this stuff. It’s so crazy.

“I’m always trying to sneak in jazz voicings and chords, little techniques here and there in Metallica.”

But when Clark asks whether he gets shot down, Hammett responds, “All the time. ‘That sounds too bluesy.’ And I’m like, ‘Fucking hell, it’s just a slide. All right, whatever, tone police.’ But you need tone police. Tone is super-important.”

Of course, Hammett - who has myriad signature guitars, owns his own pedal company, bought Peter Green’s '59 Les Paul and once sold a Dumble because it didn’t sound “kickass” enough - knows the importance of tone.

But his songwriting impact on Metallica’s latest release, 2016’s Hardwired… To Self-Destruct, was minimal after he lost his phone containing around 300 riffs - and following these comments, it sounds like not all of his solo ideas made the cut, either.

If you want to cheer Hammett up and see how solos outside of the metal giants, take a look at his guide to playing like Stevie Ray Vaughan. (Yes, really.)

Thank you for reading 5 articles this month**

Join now for unlimited access

US pricing $3.99 per month or $39.00 per year

UK pricing £2.99 per month or £29.00 per year 

Europe pricing €3.49 per month or €34.00 per year

*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription

Join now for unlimited access

Prices from £2.99/$3.99/€3.49

Michael Astley-Brown

Mike is Editor-in-Chief of, in addition to being an offset fiend and recovering pedal addict. He has a master's degree in journalism from Cardiff University, and over a decade's experience writing and editing for guitar publications including MusicRadar, Total Guitar and Guitarist, as well as 20 years of recording and live experience in original and function bands. During his career, he has interviewed the likes of John Frusciante, Chris Cornell, Tom Morello, Matt Bellamy, Kirk Hammett, Jerry Cantrell, Joe Satriani, Tom DeLonge, Ed O'Brien, Polyphia, Tosin Abasi, Yvette Young and many more. In his free time, you'll find him making progressive instrumental rock under the nom de plume Maebe.