“She put it under her bed and didn’t play it for 60 years. When I got it, it still had the original strings on it”: Why telling your guitar’s backstory could help it sell for more money

A 1959 Gibson Les Paul Standard 'Burst
(Image credit: Phil Barker/Future)

There is no shortage of advice online about buying guitars, but what about selling them? Sometimes, thinning out the herd is the hardest thing to do, and we’re not talking about sentiment here – we’re talking about how difficult it is to actually get the price you want for it.

How can we get the most out of a sale? Well, Guitarist reached out to Cyril Nigg, Data Science Leader at Reverb, to see if he had any insights. And he does.

Article continues below

The boom in YouTubing, Instagramming, and social media content creation at large might make it seem like everyone must have a pro lighting setup kicking around at home. But let’s face it. Most of us don’t. No matter, says Nigg. Just let the sun in.

“Photographing it in natural light will also help a lot,” he says. “Nowadays, you don’t need fancy equipment, you can just use your phone – most smartphones take beautiful pictures. It’s about putting yourself in the buyer’s place – what would you want to see on the guitar? Try to take those pictures.”

So put yourself in JoBo’s high-gloss polished derbies. What kind of story can you tell? Did you acquire it after a night of gambling in the backroom of a Chicago dive bar? Was it like Bonamassa’s 1941 Martin 000-45, where the previous owner sold it and managed to save her house?

Fender Custom Shop Heavy Relic 1962 Stratocaster made by Master Builder Dale Wilson

Make sure your photos capture any dings or scrapes.... Don't worry about this one, though. That happened at the Fender Custom Shop (Image credit: Future / Phil Barker)

Well, firstly, Nigg argues that full disclosure is the way to go, thereafter tell its story.

“With the descriptions, try to be thorough. Disclose anything that might be a blemish, quirk or defect,” explains Nigg. “But it can also be good to have fun with the description and tell a little bit of the backstory. I think there are times when that can be part of the attraction of buying a used instrument.”

When you know the story, there’s something a little sweeter about that versus just buying it and you don’t know anything about the guitar.

Nigg speaks from experience. He's got a sweet vintage Martin guitar back home with a real sweet story behind it.

“I bought a ’64 00-18 Martin six months ago and the story behind the guitar was really nice,” he says. “It was from a seller in Pennsylvania and she got it as a gift from her mom when she was in high school, after seeing Joan Baez.

“She put it under her bed and didn’t play it for 60 years. And when I got it, it still had the original strings on it, which, when you know the story, there’s something a little sweeter about that versus just buying it and you don’t know anything about the guitar.”

You can read Nigg’s advice in full in the latest issue of Guitarist, which you can pick up at Magazines Direct – and you’ll save a ton by subscribing.

Jonathan Horsley has been writing about guitars since 2005, playing them since 1990, and regularly contributes to publications including Guitar World, MusicRadar and Total Guitar. He uses Jazz III nylon picks, 10s during the week, 9s at the weekend, and shamefully still struggles with rhythm figure one of Van Halen’s Panama.

With contributions from

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.